Tenkara Rod Co vs. Tenkara USA: Choosing the Best Backpacking Fly Rod
As a long-time hiker, camper, and fly fishing enthusiast, I’ve spent years exploring the backcountry with a rod in hand. In recent years, I’ve become increasingly fascinated with tenkara fishing – a simple, elegant, and incredibly effective method originating in Japan. If you're looking for a fishing pole for hiking or a backpacking fly rod, you’ve likely stumbled upon two of the biggest names in the US tenkara scene: Tenkara Rod Co and Tenkara USA. Both companies offer fantastic gear, but understanding their philosophies, rod characteristics, and target audiences is crucial to choosing the right setup for your adventures. This article will break down the key differences, helping you decide between a Tenkara Rod Co rod and a Tenkara USA rod, and guide you through a tenkara rod setup.
What is Tenkara Fishing? A Quick Overview
Before diving into the brands, let’s quickly define tenkara. Unlike traditional fly fishing, tenkara doesn’t rely on a reel. Instead, it uses a long, flexible rod, a tenkara line (typically a level line), and a leader. The angler keeps the line in direct contact with the fly, allowing for incredible sensitivity and precise control. This makes it ideal for small streams and tight quarters, and it’s incredibly lightweight – perfect for backpacking fly rods. As Leave No Trace principles are paramount in backcountry fishing, tenkara’s minimalist approach aligns well with responsible outdoor ethics.
Tenkara Rod Co: The American Innovator
Tenkara Rod Co, founded by Evan Burckhardt, is often credited with popularizing tenkara in the United States. They focus on designing rods specifically for American waters and fishing styles. Their approach is heavily influenced by traditional Japanese tenkara but adapted for larger rivers, bigger fish, and the diverse conditions found across the US. They are known for their robust construction and willingness to experiment with materials and designs.
Key Characteristics of Tenkara Rod Co Rods
- Focus on Versatility: Tenkara Rod Co rods are designed to handle a wider range of fly sizes and fish species.
- Stronger Rods: Generally, their rods have a bit more backbone than Tenkara USA’s, making them suitable for larger trout and even smallmouth bass.
- Innovative Designs: They’ve introduced features like the “Fat Tire” series, designed for larger rivers and heavier flies.
- Made in Japan: While designed in the US, their rods are manufactured in Japan, maintaining a high level of craftsmanship.
Popular models include the Fat Tire Tenkara Rod, a favorite for larger streams, and the T Series, a versatile all-around option. I’ve personally found the Fat Tire to be excellent for navigating brushy banks and controlling larger fish.
Tenkara USA: The Traditionalist
Tenkara USA, led by Ron Mizutani, takes a more purist approach to tenkara. They prioritize replicating the traditional Japanese experience, focusing on lightweight rods and delicate presentations. Their rods are designed for smaller streams and more subtle fishing techniques. They emphasize the connection to the roots of tenkara and the art of “fishing with the fly.”
Key Characteristics of Tenkara USA Rods
- Lightweight and Delicate: Tenkara USA rods are renowned for their incredibly light weight and sensitive feel.
- Traditional Designs: They closely adhere to traditional Japanese tenkara rod designs and materials.
- Focus on Small Streams: Their rods excel in smaller, intimate streams where delicate presentations are key.
- The Sato Rod: The Tenkara USA Sato is their flagship model and a benchmark for traditional tenkara rods.
The Tenkara USA Sato is arguably the most popular tenkara rod in the US, and for good reason. It’s incredibly lightweight, casts beautifully, and provides excellent feel. I’ve used the Sato extensively in the Rocky Mountains and found it perfect for targeting wild trout in high-alpine streams. They also offer the Shizuku Tenkara Rod, a more affordable option that still delivers a fantastic tenkara experience.
Tenkara Rod Co vs. Tenkara USA: A Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Tenkara Rod Co | Tenkara USA |
|---|---|---|
| Philosophy | Americanized Tenkara, Versatility | Traditional Japanese Tenkara, Purism |
| Rod Weight | Generally Heavier | Generally Lighter |
| Backbone | More Backbone | Less Backbone |
| Target Fish | Larger Trout, Smallmouth Bass | Smaller Trout, Brook Trout |
| Stream Size | Larger Streams, Rivers | Smaller Streams, Creeks |
| Popular Models | Fat Tire, T Series | Sato, Shizuku |
Choosing the Right Rod: Considering Your Needs
So, which brand is right for you? It depends on your fishing style and the types of waters you’ll be fishing. Here’s a breakdown to help you decide:
- If you primarily fish larger streams and rivers, or target larger fish, a Tenkara Rod Co rod is likely a better choice. The added backbone will help you control bigger fish and cast heavier flies.
- If you primarily fish small streams and creeks, or prefer a more delicate presentation, a Tenkara USA rod is the way to go. The lightweight design and sensitive feel will allow you to make precise casts and detect subtle strikes.
- For backpacking, weight is a critical factor. While both brands offer lightweight options, Tenkara USA generally has the edge in this department. A mini tenkara rod, like some of the shorter options from both companies, can be a great choice for minimizing pack weight.
- Beginners might find a Tenkara USA Sato rod a good starting point. It’s relatively forgiving and easy to learn with. However, a best tenkara rod for beginners is subjective and depends on the angler’s strength and experience.
Tenkara Rod Setup: Getting Started
Once you’ve chosen your rod, setting it up is surprisingly simple. Here’s a basic tenkara rod setup:
- Assemble the Rod Sections: Most tenkara rods come in multiple sections that slide together.
- Attach the Tenkara Line: The line is typically attached to the tip of the rod using a loop-to-loop connection.
- Add the Leader: The leader is attached to the tenkara line using another loop-to-loop connection. Leader length typically ranges from 6-12 feet.
- Tie on the Fly: Use a simple knot like an improved clinch knot to attach your fly to the leader.
Resources like REI Expert Advice offer detailed instructions and videos on tenkara rod setup.
Finding Tenkara Rods Near You
While online retailers are a convenient option, supporting local businesses is always a good idea. To find tenkara rods near me, I recommend checking with local fly shops. Many fly shops are now carrying tenkara gear, and the staff can provide valuable advice and assistance. You can also use the store locator on the Tenkara Rod Co and Tenkara USA websites.
Beyond the Basics: Flies and Accessories
Choosing the right flies is just as important as choosing the right rod. Popular best tenkara flies include Kebari (traditional Japanese flies), pheasant tail nymphs, and small streamers. Other essential accessories include a fly box, nippers, forceps, and a wading staff (if you’re fishing larger streams). Don't forget a good pair of polarized sunglasses to help you spot fish!
Final Thoughts on Tenkara Rod Co vs. Tenkara USA
Both Tenkara Rod Co and Tenkara USA are excellent companies that offer high-quality tenkara gear. The best choice for you depends on your individual needs and preferences. I encourage you to do your research, read reviews, and, if possible, try out different rods before making a purchase. Whether you choose a robust rod from Tenkara Rod Co or a delicate rod from Tenkara USA, you’re sure to enjoy the simplicity, elegance, and effectiveness of tenkara fishing. Remember to always practice responsible fishing techniques and adhere to USDA Forest Service and National Park Service regulations.